Southampton - Loan system is wrong
UK time is: 05:00:23
Vital Login
Social Login

Choose your club

Other Sites

Network Navigation

Vital Partners

'If It's Football, It's Vital'

Loan system is wrong

With the news that Bolton have signed Danny Guthrie on a season long loan from Liverpool, I have to question the loan system.

This might sound like sour grapes as I would have loved to see him back at Southampton next season.

But Southampton themselves have also been guilty of it, with Inigo Idiakez having a spell at QPR just last season.

So what is my issue? Well it's loaning players to teams in the same division. Personally I think it is wrong and doesn't help teams further down the football league pyramid.

Football teams, especially in the Premiership, are now bigger in size then they ever used to be.

These players either waste their time in the reserves league or go out on loan with little or no chance of ever breaking into their first team squad.

But do we support a strong Football League by loaning players down the divisions? No you get Ben Foster spending a year in the Premiership with Watford before returning to Manchester United and Danny Guthrie joining Bolton from Liverpool.

Did it do Leon Best any harm going down a league to Yeovil? He came back and broke into the Southampton team due to his goal scoring form and obviously our disastrous luck with injuries.

Even David Beckham spent time at lower league side Bury.

It didn't adversely affect them and I believe the FA should do something about it.

Use your social login to comment on front page articles. Login using you Facebook, Twitter, Google or LinkedIn accounts and have your say!

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

The Journalist

Writer:  Mail feedback, articles or suggestions

Date:Thursday June 21 2007

Time: 1:36PM

Your Comments (oldest first)

Change to most recent first
Ive got to say I agree but Benitez and his staff will disagree as they get to see Guthrie competing in the Premiership, giving them a good idea of whether he can cut it at the top level. Theyre not going to get much much information from a man of the match display against Burnley because it wont mean he can do the same at Old Trafford.
Report Abuse
21/06/2007 14:09:00

Interesting viewpoint but I believe that what you're proposing is impractical. Firstly, from a legal point of view, it would probably be viewed as a restriction of trade, and if that's the case it wouldn't get off the drawing board. Secondly, Premiership teams need loans too (they don't all have huge budgets), so your system would penalise those teams, such as Bolton, that don't have huge financial clout. Lastly, there are three parties in any trade, the player, his team and the team taking him on loan, and it seems to me that your solution will, in some cases, hurt the most important party, the player, by denying him the best possible opportunity to develop his career and that can't be right.
Harry P
Report Abuse
21/06/2007 14:24:00

Interesting article and you can certainly see both sides to the argument. Having gained promotion last season utilising the loan system not surprisingly I'll disagree with you...for now!
Report Abuse
21/06/2007 15:40:00

I agree totally, now let us have some of your best players on loan, as us Bristol Rovers fans are in desperate need of some new faces to add to our fast improving squad lol, worth a try
Report Abuse
21/06/2007 20:42:00


Have Your Say

Log in...
with your social network     OR     with your Vital account

Recent Southampton Articles

McCarthy Heads To Adams Park (Tuesday October 13 2015)

Stekelenburg Gets Dutch Call (Monday October 12 2015)

The Southampton Injury Table.. (Friday October 9 2015)

Arsenal Selected For TV (Thursday October 8 2015)

All About The Wanyama (Tuesday October 6 2015)

Three In Team Of The Week (Monday October 5 2015)

Trio Talk Chelsea (Monday October 5 2015)

Ward-Prowse Makes 100 (Monday October 5 2015)

Archived Southampton Articles

List All Vital Saints Articles
Have your say
Click here to suggest an article
Click here to suggest a poll
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites

Vital Members League (view all)

1. Vital Saint 16

League Results (view all)

League Table (view table)

Team P W D L GD Pts
6. West Ham 8 4 2 2 6 14
7. Everton 8 3 4 1 4 13
8. Spurs 8 3 4 1 4 13
9. Southampton 8 3 3 2 3 12
10. Liverpool 8 3 3 2 -2 12
11. Swansea 8 2 4 2 0 10
12. Watford 8 2 4 2 -1 10

Southampton Fixtures (view all)

Breaking League News

Don`t Rely on Lady Luck!
Chelsea : 13/10/2015 18:51:00
Sullivan Quashes Tomkins Newcastle Rumours
West Ham : 13/10/2015 18:43:00
Hammers Go Dutch!
West Ham : 13/10/2015 18:35:00
Ref Watch: Madley to officiate Swansea v Stoke
Stoke : 13/10/2015 18:32:00
Ivanovic Is Out - What Would You Do?
Chelsea : 13/10/2015 17:53:00

Current Site Poll (view all polls)

Chelsea MotM
Suggested By:  Site Staff
Stekelenburg 6%
Soares 0%
Fonte 0%
van Dijk 3%
Bertrand 7%
Romeu 0%
Wanyama 0%
Mane 11%
S Davis 7%
Tadic 7%
Pelle 53%
Sub - Ward-Prowse 3%
Sub - Rodriguez 0%
Sub - Yoshida 3%