Vital Football

Latest Southampton FC News

The Burley Debate

The Burley Debate

George Burley has come in for a lot of stick recently, and I think that a reasoned argument in his defence needed to be written. In his time here, George has:

a) nurtured Surman, Jones and Baird into top players and therefore earned the club a lot of money. each one has in the past expressed their admiration for him and his loyalty in them.

b) stuck it out while the board squabbled like little children. being a football manager is difficult at the best of times but not knowing who you are working for and not being allowed to get settled must make it very hard indeed.

c)We are playing some good football (not in the 2 games this season admittedly) and a small improvement on last season may well be enough. THAT night at Pride Park was one of the proudest in my life.

d) Although some say he wasted the £7million, he has also done some sound business for less money. Viafara now looks a snip, Rasiak was a good buy, Hammill and Guthrie are excellent for loans, we made a profit on pele, Skacel's form, although inconsistent, has been enough to convince me that he is good enough. not to mention Saga...

e) Changing the manager now would be disasterous for the current squad. So many players would want to jump ship and it would be years before we could think of challenging again, if we are lucky enough to avoid relegation in the transition period.

f) he's only had 18 months. its no good saying 'well Billy Davies did it in a year' because at the end of the day, a penalty shootout is what divided us and them. if we can sign some good centre halves, we have a good chance this year. get rid of burley, and this season may as well be a write off.

g) There is nobody else that we could realistically target to take over who would do a better job. Dodd is far too inexperienced, Hoddle has failed miserably in his last two jobs and has all the man management skills of a flannell, Jewell has said he won't take another job until next season, and Warnock is not the type of man we want leading out club through this difficult period.

We must stick this out, as if we support our manager, I for one really am confident that we can make this seaosn a successful one.



Join the Vital Fantasy Football League - its Free!

Writer:Chris Mitchell
Date:Wednesday August 15 2007
Time: 2:15PM

Login to post a comment

Best of Vital Network

Vital Boxing - Tyson Fury Retires?

Recent Southampton Articles

Hojbjerg Praises French Trip

Midfielder Pierre-Emile Hojbjerg has said he believes an intensive week of training out in France will more than bring the group together now our internationals are back...

French Trip Will Be Good For Southampton

Manager Mauricio Pellegrino has said he feels Southampton's trip to France for a second training camp this pre season will be good for everyone.

Pellegrino Reflects On Brentford Draw

Southampton manager Mauricio Pellegrino and Charlie Auston have reflected on the weekend's draw with Brentford at Griffin Park.

AFCON Boost For League Sides From 2019

Changes to the African Cup of Nations have provided Premier League teams with a boost from the season of 2018/19.

Archived Vital Saints Articles

Vital Saints articles from

Site Journalists

SFC Forever
no email
Profile
Vital Saint
Editor email
Profile
Matt Gardner
no email
Profile

Current Poll (see more polls)

Stoke MotM
Suggested By:
Forster6%
Soares1%
Stephens15%
Yoshida4%
Bertrand3%
Davis4%
Romeu6%
Tadic4%
Ward-Prowse3%
Redmond39%
Austin6%
Sub - Boufal3%
Sub - Gabbiadini3%
Sub - Pied3%
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Vital Football Comment
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Write for Vital Football

Recent Southampton Results (view all)

Southampton Fixtures (view all)

The Vital Football Members League